Payroll revisions shift the case for another Fed hike onto inflation
BLS revisions cut 60,000 jobs from July and August payrolls, turning July into a 10,000 loss, before September added just 29,000. With August PCE inflation at 3.4%, the case for another hike after the Fed's September move to 3.75%-4% now rests mostly on prices.
The Investor · Invest desk
What happened
- Economists had expected 84,000 September payrolls, and the unemployment rate rose to 4.2% from 4.1%.
- Average hourly earnings rose 0.1% on the month and 3.0% on the year, below the 0.3% and 3.1% first reported for August.
- After the report, CME FedWatch priced an 18% chance of an October hike and a 69% chance of one in December.
- Spot gold rose 0.6% to $4,165.49 an ounce on Monday, and December gold futures gained 0.8% to $4,194.60.
Why it matters
- What doesn't add up contradiction CryptoSlate says the report weakens the labor case for a hike, yet futures still favor a December increase, so traders are pricing the Fed on inflation with payrolls set aside.
- What it costs cost Pay growth trailing August PCE inflation by about 0.4 point means wages are losing ground to prices, a gap workers carry whatever the Fed decides.
- Who has to decide decision The Fed's Sept. 16 statement said job gains had kept pace with the workforce; its next statement has to square that with a July that now shows a loss.
Next story · Invest · yesterday
Crypto liquidations hit $948 million as Bitcoin dips under $80,000 after hot PPI data, 90.6% of them longsConfirmed13 publishers
The 60,000 splits almost evenly between the two months: July lost 31,000 from its prior estimate and August lost 29,000 [15]. When the Fed hiked on Sept. 16, July and August together showed 183,000 jobs [8][16]. They now show 123,000 [16].
CryptoSlate noted that the revision corrects jobs already counted and adds no new September losses [4]. Averaged with September, payrolls grew by about 50,700 a month over the quarter [18].
September on its own settles little. BLS puts its approximate significance thresholds at 122,000 for a monthly payroll change and 650,000 for the household survey, and September's changes fell below both [17]. The 29,000 payroll gain is about a quarter of its threshold [26]. The household survey counted 406,000 more people employed, but its labor force grew by 485,000 [9], leaving roughly 79,000 more people unemployed [25].
The September hike was the Fed's first in three years and followed five straight holds, the last of them a 9-3 July vote in which three regional bank presidents dissented in favor of a quarter-point increase [11]. From here the committee could read the revisions as removing its labor rationale and stop after one move. It could hike again on inflation alone, with core PCE still at 3.0% in August against a 2% goal [14]. Futures favor that outcome for December [19]. Or hiring could firm and restore the labor argument.
I think the revisions carry more weight than the September print. They move two months the Fed had in hand when it hiked, while the 29,000 sits below BLS's significance threshold [17]. A December hike would then be justified by prices, with the labor half of the September argument gone. CryptoSlate made a narrower version of the point: weak hiring and slower wage growth give less support for tightening meant to restrain labor demand [6].
The counter-thesis has two parts. Participation rose to 61.8% from 61.6% [9], evidence a hawk can cite of a labor market still absorbing workers. And SchiffGold, the bullion dealer founded by Peter Schiff, ran its analysis under the headline "The Fed Is Going To Ignore Another Weak Jobs Report", arguing the year-to-date payroll total still underperforms despite the household survey's strength [24]. Stronger inflation or hiring would undo the softer reading, CryptoSlate wrote [5].
Gold rose even as the dollar index added 0.22%, a move that raises the cost of dollar-priced metals for buyers in other currencies [21]. "We continue to view rising government debt levels as a structural tailwind for the yellow metal," UBS analyst Giovanni Staunovo told Reuters [22]. Total U.S. debt topped $40 trillion for the first time in August [23].
CryptoSlate argued that a softer labor case could ease the discount-rate threat to bitcoin [29], and in the same piece cited a February 2023 New York Fed staff study that found bitcoin largely unresponsive to monetary and macroeconomic surprises in an intraday event study [28].
What to watch
- The September FOMC minutes, due Wednesday, will show whether support for tightening reached beyond July's three dissenters.
- The Nov. 6 jobs report: further downward revisions would erode the labor case again, while a payroll gain above the 122,000 significance threshold would revive it.
- September PCE inflation: a reading above August's 3.4% would support a December hike whatever payrolls do.
Information, not investment advice. This story is general information about companies and markets, drawn from cited reporting. It is not a recommendation to buy, sell or hold any security; check the cited sources before acting.
Clarity's read
What the record supports and how the coverage leans. The claims behind it follow.
Reality
- Evidence72
- Adoption
- Not scored
- Hype gap+10
- Incentives55
- Confidence66
Perspective Coverage
3 publishers- Builder
- Builder 7%
- Operator
- Operator 15%
- Investor
- Investor 78%
Claim ledger
Ranked by verification strength, evidence, and original report placement.
- [1]
The US Bureau of Labor Statistics revised July and August payroll gains down by 60,000 on Oct. 2.
- [2]
The September employment report put payroll growth at 29,000.
- [3]
July's payroll estimate flipped from 21,000 jobs added to 10,000 lost; August's fell from 162,000 to 133,000.
- [4]
The 60,000 adjustment revises earlier estimates rather than identifying new September job losses.
- [5]
Stronger subsequent inflation or hiring would weaken the interpretation that the report softens the labor case for tightening.
- [6]
Weak hiring and slower reported wage growth provide less support for tightening policy to restrain labor demand.
- [7]
Employers added 29,000 nonfarm payrolls in September against the 84,000 gain economists had expected; the unemployment rate ticked up to 4.2% from 4.1%.
- [8]
The Fed raised rates by a quarter point on Sept. 16 to a 3.75%-4% target range; its statement said job gains had kept pace with the workforce and inflation remained elevated.
- [9]
In the household survey, employment rose an estimated 406,000, participation moved from 61.6% to 61.8%, unemployment edged from 4.1% to 4.2%, and the labor force grew by 485,000.
- [10]
The next jobs release is scheduled for Nov. 6.
- [11]
The September hike was the Fed's first in three years and followed five consecutive meetings with rates unchanged; at the July meeting the committee voted 9-3 to hold, with three regional bank presidents dissenting in favor of a quarter-point increase.
- [12]
Minutes from the September FOMC meeting are due Wednesday.
- [13]
Average hourly earnings for all employees on private nonfarm payrolls rose 0.1% monthly and 3.0% annually, below the 0.3% and 3.1% originally reported for August.
- [14]
August PCE inflation, released Sept. 30, ran at 3.4% annually, or 3.0% excluding food and energy; both exceeded the Fed's 2% goal.
- [15]
July's estimate fell by 31,000 and August's by 29,000, together accounting for the 60,000 revision.
- [16]
July and August together showed 183,000 jobs before the Oct. 2 revision and 123,000 after it.
- [17]
September's monthly employment changes were below BLS's approximate significance thresholds of 650,000 for households and 122,000 for payrolls.
- [18]
Payrolls grew by about 50,700 a month on average across July, August and September after revisions.
- [19]
The CME FedWatch Tool showed traders pricing an 18% probability of a rate hike at the Fed's October meeting and a 69% chance of an increase in December.
- [20]
By 0901 GMT Monday, spot gold was up 0.6% at $4,165.49 per ounce, while U.S. gold futures for December delivery were up 0.8% at $4,194.60.
- [21]
The U.S. dollar index added 0.22% on Monday, a move that raises the effective cost of dollar-priced commodities for buyers using other currencies and acted as a brake on gold's gains.
- [22]
"We continue to view rising government debt levels as a structural tailwind for the yellow metal," UBS analyst Giovanni Staunovo told Reuters.
- [23]
Total U.S. debt topped $40 trillion for the first time in August.
- [24]
SchiffGold, a precious metals dealer founded by Peter Schiff, published an analysis headlined "The Fed Is Going To Ignore Another Weak Jobs Report", arguing the year-to-date payroll number still underperforms despite the household survey's outperformance.
- [25]
The household survey implies roughly 79,000 more unemployed people in September.
- [26]
September's 29,000 payroll gain is about a quarter of BLS's 122,000 significance threshold.
- [27]
Annual pay growth of 3.0% in September trails August's 3.4% PCE inflation by about 0.4 percentage point.
- [28]
A February 2023 New York Fed staff study found Bitcoin largely unresponsive to monetary and macroeconomic surprises in an intraday event study.
- [29]
For Bitcoin, a softer labor case could reduce the threat of higher discount rates, a potential pressure on speculative assets.
Sources
3 independent publishers whose own reporting we read for this story.
- cryptoslate.comUS jobs revision turns July’s 21,000 gain into a 10,000 loss
1 article · October 5, 2026
- qz.comGold climbs as weak September jobs report dims Fed rate-hike odds
1 article · October 5, 2026
- seekingalpha.comThe Fed Is Going To Ignore Another Weak Jobs Report
1 article · October 5, 2026
Topics and entities
Topics
- Federal Reserve Monetary Policy
- U.S. Labor Market
- Gold and precious metals
- US Inflation