Bitcoin gained 38% while CLARITY's odds of passing fell from 39% to 18%
Bitwise's Matt Hougan says the Senate's 49-50 cloture failure will not end the crypto rally, and points to a summer in which prices rose as the odds of passage halved. Only Congress can give the CFTC spot authority.
The Investor · Invest desk
What happened
- The Senate rejected cloture on the Digital Asset Market Clarity Act on September 15 by 49-50, short of the 60 votes needed to bring the bill to the floor.
- Every Democrat voted against the measure, and several Republicans joined them.
- The SEC proposed its Regulation Crypto Assets package in August, and Chair Paul Atkins has said the agency is prepared to write rules on many of the stalled bill's topics.
Why it matters
- Who's exposed exposure A rulebook written at the SEC and CFTC can be rewritten by the next SEC and CFTC, so a firm that launches on agency permission between now and the midterms is operating on a revocable one.
- What it limits constraint The feature Hougan wanted from the bill was rules that outlast the current administration, and no agency package supplies that, however quickly it is drafted.
- What doesn't add up contradiction Hougan values the same statute at close to nothing on the downside and at a clear premium on the upside, and which half you believe decides whether the vote was a non-event or a lost quarter.
- Who has to decide decision Anyone who deferred a US product until a statute existed now has to decide whether a CFTC framework and an SEC proposal are cover enough, because that is the only text arriving this year.
Next story · Invest · yesterday
A BIS model of rising output and a thinner consumer market sits outside Bitwise's three Bitcoin pathsConfirmed4 publishers
The move Hougan measures against is about 38 percent, bitcoin's July 1 low near $57,950 to above $80,000 on September 4 [8][18]. Over the same weeks the implied probability that CLARITY becomes law in 2026 fell 21 points, from 39 to 18 percent, more than half the starting number [20][22]. The roughly 4 percent decline the day after the cloture vote gave back about a tenth of the summer's advance [1][19]. Crowdfund Insider does not name the prediction market [21].
Two readings fit. Either the statute was never in the price, or it was and rates and energy priced over it in a single session; Hougan put the one-day drop down partly to concurrent concerns about interest rates and energy prices [1].
The rule pipeline he is betting on is real but narrow. Atkins has said the SEC is prepared to issue rules covering many of the same topics as the stalled bill, and the commission proposed a Regulation Crypto Assets package in August [12]. Selig has indicated the CFTC can publish its own framework quickly [13]. Hougan thinks those rules could prove more innovation-friendly in the near term than a compromise statute. He grants that agency actions can later be reversed, and that only Congress can give the CFTC full authority over spot markets [14].
His evidence for institutional indifference is three launches: Robinhood's own blockchain, a Morgan Stanley Solana exchange-traded product, and DTCC production settlements of tokenized securities [11]. Those firms already had "clarity of conviction" because a crypto-friendly SEC and CFTC remain in place through 2029, he said [10].
The memo holds two prices for the same bill. He wrote that the data suggest its fate matters less than headlines imply [7]. He also says passage would have made digital assets the consensus fourth-quarter trade and almost certainly driven prices higher [15]. And the forecast moved after the tape did: earlier in the year he likened the bill to crypto's Punxsutawney Phil and warned that defeat could bring several more weeks of difficult trading toward the midterms, then dropped that call after reviewing recent market behavior [3].
In my view the divergence carries more weight than the memo's optimism, and the thesis breaks in one of two ways. Either the SEC and CFTC packages land and prices move sharply on them, in which case regulatory progress is still priced and has moved from roll-call votes to rulemaking dockets. Or the packages slow in litigation and the 49-50 tally binds, because spot authority needs 11 more Senate votes than cloture got [4][17]. Hougan's own base rate is the seventeen years the industry spent without a market-structure statute while becoming a $2.5 trillion asset class [16].
What to watch
- Whether the SEC's Regulation Crypto Assets package moves from proposal to final rule, and how prices respond when it does.
- Whether Selig's CFTC publishes a framework that reaches into spot markets, and whether it is litigated.
- Whether a second cloture attempt before the midterms finds the 11 additional votes.
Information, not investment advice. This story is general information about companies and markets, drawn from cited reporting. It is not a recommendation to buy, sell or hold any security; check the cited sources before acting.
Clarity's read
What the record supports and how the coverage leans. The claims behind it follow.
Reality
- Evidence50
- Adoption40
- Hype gap+30
- Incentives60
- Confidence55
Perspective Coverage
3 publishers- Builder
- Builder 7%
- Operator
- Operator 13%
- Investor
- Investor 80%
Claim ledger
Ranked by verification strength, evidence, and original report placement.
- [1]
Hougan acknowledged the immediate market reaction was negative: bitcoin declined roughly 4 percent the day after the vote, a move he viewed as understandable given concurrent concerns about interest rates and energy prices.
- [2]
In a September 16 memo, Bitwise CIO Matt Hougan argued the Senate's failure to advance the CLARITY Act is unlikely to halt the cryptocurrency rally that began in early July, recasting the setback as a temporary obstacle.
- [3]
Earlier in the year Hougan had likened the legislation to crypto's version of Punxsutawney Phil, warning that defeat could bring several more weeks of difficult trading lasting toward the midterms; after reviewing recent market behavior he abandoned that forecast.
- [4]
On September 15 the Senate rejected cloture on the Digital Asset Market Clarity Act by a 49-50 vote, short of the 60 votes needed to proceed.
- [5]
Every Democrat opposed the measure, along with several Republicans.
- [6]
Matt Hougan is chief investment officer of Bitwise.
- [7]
The data, Hougan wrote, suggest the bill's fate matters less than headlines imply.
- [8]
The rally started July 1, when bitcoin found a low near $57,950; by September 4 the asset had climbed above $80,000.
- [9]
Hougan called the outcome unfortunate, describing the bill as a constructive framework that would have improved investor safeguards and created durable rules extending beyond the current administration.
- [10]
Hougan said those firms already possessed "clarity of conviction" because a crypto-friendly Securities and Exchange Commission and Commodity Futures Trading Commission remain in place through 2029.
- [11]
In recent months Robinhood launched its own blockchain, Morgan Stanley introduced a Solana exchange-traded product, and the Depository Trust & Clearing Corporation completed production settlements of tokenized securities.
- [12]
SEC Chair Paul Atkins has stated the agency is prepared to issue rules covering many of the same topics as the stalled bill, and the commission already proposed a Regulation Crypto Assets package in August.
- [13]
CFTC Chair Mike Selig has indicated his agency is ready to publish its own framework quickly.
- [14]
Hougan believes forthcoming agency rules could prove more innovation-friendly in the near term than a compromise statute, even though agency actions can later be reversed and only Congress can grant the CFTC full authority over spot markets.
- [15]
Hougan said passage would have made digital assets the consensus fourth-quarter trade and almost certainly driven prices higher, and that absent that catalyst additional bumps remain.
- [16]
Cryptocurrency operated for seventeen years without comprehensive market-structure legislation and still grew into a $2.5 trillion asset class.
- [17]
Cloture fell 11 votes short of the 60 needed.
- [18]
Bitcoin's move from a July 1 low near $57,950 to above $80,000 on September 4 is a gain of about 38 percent.
- [19]
The roughly 4 percent post-vote decline equals about a tenth of the 38 percent advance since July 1.
- [20]
Over that same window, prediction-market odds that CLARITY would become law in 2026 dropped from 39 percent to 18 percent.
- [21]
The Crowdfund Insider account does not identify the prediction market whose odds it cites.
- [22]
The fall in CLARITY passage odds from 39 percent to 18 percent is a drop of 21 percentage points, or about 54 percent of the starting probability.
Sources
3 independent publishers whose own reporting we read for this story.
- cointelegraph.comBitcoin hits $81K as US bond yields rebound on global oil woes
1 article · September 18, 2026
- crowdfundinsider.comBitwise CIO Matt Hougan Says CLARITY Act Setback Unlikely to End Bitcoin and Crypto Bull Run
2 articles · September 20, 2026
- decrypt.coBitcoin Blasts Past $80K and a Fresh Short Squeeze Is On
1 article · September 18, 2026