Skip to content

Science Independently confirmed2 publishers 2 min read Published Updated

Memory T cells' balance of granzyme K and granzyme B tracks with how healthily people age

Washington University's Maxim Artyomov and colleagues link memory T cells favoring granzyme K over granzyme B to healthier aging in a study in Immunity. The 17-year link to illness and death comes from UK Biobank adults whose cell levels were estimated from blood proteins, so the case for an aging blood test is still indirect.

The Scientist · Science desk

Send a correction

Illustration accompanying Memory T cells' balance of granzyme K and granzyme B tracks with how healthily people age
Generated illustration
Health links are supported; an aging blood test is not yet Verifier states for the study's central claims: the granzyme K/B ratio's links to health, the causation caveat, and the proposed aging test.

Evidence map. Supported: more granzyme K than B memory cells, healthier aging; lower K-to-B ratio, more immune conditions; more predicted granzyme B cells, worse UK Biobank health; no proof of causation. Insufficient: the ratio as an aging blood test.

Health links are supported; an aging blood test is not yet
ClaimStateClaim number
A study published Friday (Oct. 9) in the journal Immunity found that individuals with more memory cells that make granzyme K than cells that make granzyme B tend to have healthier aging.Supported1
The researchers analyzed immune cells sampled from over 2,600 people ages 18 to 97 and found that people with a lower ratio of granzyme K to granzyme B cell populations were more likely to have autoimmune diseases or other chronic immune conditions.Supported3
In around 48,000 UK Biobank participants, people predicted from their blood proteins to have higher levels of granzyme B-making cells had worse health outcomes over the following 17 years, with higher risk of death and of conditions like diabetes, high blood pressure, and liver and kidney disease.Supported5
Artyomov emphasized that the study does not prove the ratio directly causes poor health outcomes, and further studies are needed to understand why more granzyme B cells are linked with poorer health.Supported6
Artyomov told Live Science that in the future the balance of cells making granzyme K and granzyme B in a person's blood could be used as a test to determine "whether you're on the right trajectory of aging or not."Insufficient evidence17

What happened

  • In over 2,600 people aged 18 to 97, a lower ratio of granzyme K to granzyme B cells went with more autoimmune and other chronic immune conditions.
  • Across about 48,000 UK Biobank participants, higher predicted granzyme B levels went with diabetes, high blood pressure, and liver and kidney disease.
  • Artyomov said granzyme K cells are the more mature, specialized stage in mice, while in humans granzyme B cells fit that description.
  • Artyomov stressed that the study does not prove the ratio causes poor health, and that further work is needed to explain the link.

Why it matters

  • What doesn't add up contradiction The team's own mouse work tied granzyme K cells to inflammation, so carrying mouse results over to people would point to the opposite conclusion from the human data.
  • What it limits constraint Validating the ratio as a human biomarker has to happen in human cohorts, because Gustafson says the relevant biology is not reflected in animal models.
  • Who has to decide decision If the ratio turns out to be a consequence of disease, it could still flag risk in a screen, but it would offer no case for treatments that try to shift it.

Next story · Science · Sep 17

An inherited EGFR variant carried 62-fold lung cancer odds among never-smokers

Confirmed2 publishers

Only the first of the study's three analyses counts cells directly. In the 2,600-person group, the team compared each person's balance of granzyme K- and granzyme B-making memory T cells with the immune conditions that person had [3]. Granzymes are the proteins these cells use to kill infected cells [10].

The 17 years of follow-up come from UK Biobank, a database of health data from U.K. adults [9]. There, granzyme B cell levels were predicted from blood proteins. The predictor was a signature the team built from 329 people who gave both immune cells and protein samples [4][5]. The roughly 48,000 participants it was applied to outnumber that group about 146 to one [16]. Any gap between the signature and real cell counts carries into every Biobank result.

Artyomov, a co-author and immunologist at Washington University in St. Louis, told Live Science the balance could one day be a test of "whether you're on the right trajectory of aging or not" [2][17]. I think the evidence supports the ratio as a candidate marker for that job. Its long-range case still rests on the protein stand-in. Live Science's report does not give effect sizes, and it does not say whether the signature predicts more than age alone does [5].

Artyomov also warned against reading the link as cause. "This observation might be just a consequence, not a cause of the disease," he said [7]. In the 2,600-person data, a chronic immune condition could itself shift a person's cell balance, and the association would look the same [3].

The team's earlier work makes the human result harder to read. In old lab mice, granzyme K-making cells built up in several tissues and were linked to inflammation, and older adults' blood showed the same rise in granzyme K cells [11]. In the new study, people whose cells lean toward granzyme K tend to age in better health [1]. Claire Gustafson, an immunologist at the Allen Institute who was not involved, called the species difference "underappreciated" [14]. When comparing these cells in mice and humans, "we're not looking at apples to apples," she said [14].

"I think that's really exciting," Gustafson said of the results [13]. "It highlights there's potentially some novel biology that we haven't really observed before," she said [15]. She also said immune features vary across human populations, and that a "true understanding of universal immune health" needs more data from them [8].

What to watch

  • Published effect sizes for the UK Biobank signature, showing whether it predicts death and disease beyond what age and routine clinical tests already capture.
  • A cohort that counts granzyme K and B cells directly at baseline and follows people for years, testing whether the protein-proxy association over 17 years holds up.

Clarity's read

What the record supports and how the coverage leans. The claims behind it follow.

Reality

Evidence60
Adoption
Not scored
Hype gap+25
Incentives35
Confidence58
Why these scores

Claim ledger

Ranked by verification strength, evidence, and original report placement.

  1. [1]

    A study published Friday (Oct. 9) in the journal Immunity found that individuals with more memory cells that make granzyme K than cells that make granzyme B tend to have healthier aging.

    Reported Supported Source: Live ScienceView cited source
  2. [2]

    Maxim Artyomov, an immunologist at Washington University in St. Louis, is a co-author of the study.

    Reported SupportedView cited source
  3. [3]

    The researchers analyzed immune cells sampled from over 2,600 people ages 18 to 97 and found that people with a lower ratio of granzyme K to granzyme B cell populations were more likely to have autoimmune diseases or other chronic immune conditions.

    Reported SupportedView cited source
  4. [4]

    In a second analysis, the team used immune cells and blood-borne proteins sampled from 329 people to pinpoint a protein signature linked to an abundance of granzyme B-making cells.

    Reported SupportedView cited source
  5. [5]

    In around 48,000 UK Biobank participants, people predicted from their blood proteins to have higher levels of granzyme B-making cells had worse health outcomes over the following 17 years, with higher risk of death and of conditions like diabetes, high blood pressure, and liver and kidney disease.

    Reported SupportedView cited source
  6. [6]

    Artyomov emphasized that the study does not prove the ratio directly causes poor health outcomes, and further studies are needed to understand why more granzyme B cells are linked with poorer health.

    Reported Supported Source: Maxim ArtyomovView cited source
  7. [7]

    "This observation might be just a consequence, not a cause of the disease."

    Reported Supported Source: Maxim ArtyomovView cited source
  8. [8]

    Gustafson said immune cells' features vary across diverse human populations and more data across populations is needed to get a "true understanding of universal immune health."

    Reported Supported Source: Claire GustafsonView cited source
  9. [9]

    The UK Biobank is a large database of health data from U.K.-based adults.

    Reported SupportedView cited source
  10. [10]

    Exposure to pathogens and vaccinations turns some naive T cells into memory cells, which make proteins called granzymes, including granzyme K and granzyme B, that kill infected cells.

    Reported SupportedView cited source
  11. [11]

    In earlier research, the same team found that granzyme K-making cells accumulated in several tissues of old lab mice and were linked to inflammation, and observed the same increase in granzyme K cells in blood samples from older adults.

    Reported SupportedView cited source
  12. [12]

    Granzyme K-making cells in mice are not the same as in humans: in mice they represent a more mature, specialized stage of immune cell development, whereas in humans granzyme B cells better fit that description, Artyomov told Live Science.

    Reported Supported Source: Maxim Artyomov, to Live ScienceView cited source
  13. [13]

    "I think that's really exciting," said Claire Gustafson, an immunologist at the Allen Institute who was not involved in the research.

    Reported Supported Source: Claire Gustafson, Allen InstituteView cited source
  14. [14]

    Gustafson said the mouse-human difference was "underappreciated" before; comparing these cells in mice and humans, "we're not looking at apples to apples"; scientists "need to look more into humans, as it's not reflected in animal models."

    Reported Supported Source: Claire GustafsonView cited source
  15. [15]

    "It highlights there's potentially some novel biology that we haven't really observed before."

    Reported Supported Source: Claire GustafsonView cited source
  16. [16]

    The UK Biobank cohort the protein signature was applied to is about 146 times the size of the 329-person group it was built in.

    Derived Supported
  17. [17]

    Artyomov told Live Science that in the future the balance of cells making granzyme K and granzyme B in a person's blood could be used as a test to determine "whether you're on the right trajectory of aging or not."

    Reported Insufficient Source: Maxim Artyomov, to Live ScienceView cited source

Sources

2 independent publishers whose own reporting we read for this story.

  1. genengnews.com

    1 article · October 9, 2026

    Immune Cell Atlas Charts How People’s Aging Paths Diverge
  2. livescience.com

    1 article · October 9, 2026

    Scientists have identified a 'protein signature' in blood that could predict healthy aging

Topics and entities

Topics

  • Aging biomarkers
  • Immune Aging and Immunosenescence

Entities