Barn owls nesting on West 75th Street are a Manhattan first, Cornell's Andrew Farnsworth says
Barn owls are nesting in a West 75th Street water tower, a Manhattan first in recorded history, says Cornell Lab of Ornithology's Andrew Farnsworth. New York's Department of Environmental Conservation says the barn owl population has declined "at an alarming rate."
The Scientist · Science desk
David Barrett says he has seen five barn owl fledglings at the water tower. Some photographers claim to have seen six fledglings, Barrett says, and two adult owls are believed to be there, he adds.
| Figure | Value | Note | Claim |
|---|---|---|---|
| Barn owl fledglings Barrett has seen at the water tower | 5 fledglings | 12 | |
| Fledglings some photographers claim to have seen | 6 fledglings | photographers' claim, per Barrett | 14 |
| Adult barn owls believed to be there | 2 adults | believed, per Barrett | 14 |
What happened
- Resident Elisabeth Williams alerted a local news outlet on Oct. 6 after she and her husband saw multiple owls at the tower.
- The couple had heard periodic screeching outside since early September, and a phone app identified the sound as a barn owl.
- New York City's Parks department says barn owl sightings in city parks are very rare.
- Photographers and onlookers gather on the street most nights hoping to see the owls.
Why it matters
- What doesn't add up contradiction A new nest and a state-recorded decline can both be true, so the nest alone is not evidence that city habitat is supporting the species.
- What it limits constraint "First" here means first in the collective birding knowledge Farnsworth cites, so it cannot rule out an earlier nest that nobody noticed.
- Who's exposed exposure Fledglings fed on city rodents can be exposed to whatever those rodents carry, and one onlooker voiced worry about rodenticide.
Next story · Science · Sep 22
Sydney cockatoos pass their bin-opening skills to neighbouring flocksOne report1 publisher
The nest rests on direct observation. David Barrett, a Manhattan birder who runs the Manhattan Bird Alert account, said he has observed at least one adult and five fledglings at the water tower on West 75th Street [12][1]. He added that two adults are believed to be present, and some photographers claim six fledglings [14].
The "first" belongs to Farnsworth, and he framed it as a statement about what birders know. He said: "To the best of our knowledge, like the collective birding knowledge, there hasn't been a nest in, you know, in Manhattan, at least in recorded history." [2] Of the owls themselves he said: "It was, like, totally shocking." [3]
Barrett stressed the family. He said: "Having one barn owl is a rarity, but it's not national news. Having a family, for the first time ever, breeding in Manhattan in recorded history, that's special news." [10]
We would not stretch that into a claim about habitat. New York sits at the northern fringe of the barn owl's range [7]. The only population trend in the Phys.org account is the state's, and it is a decline [8]. A nest on one block fits a declining species as easily as a recovering one, and a count of fledglings at a single tower cannot separate the two. It is not known where the rodents were caught, or whether any other pair is nesting in the city.
What to watch
- Whether the fledglings leave the tower and survive, and whether birders report any second nest elsewhere in the city.
- Any formal survey that counts the birds or checks other buildings. A survey like that would show whether one nest says anything about habitat.
- Any testing of the owls or their prey for rodenticide.
Clarity's read
What the record supports and how the coverage leans. The claims behind it follow.
Reality
- Evidence55
- Adoption
- Not scored
- Hype gap+10
- Incentives
- Not scored
- Confidence65
Perspective Coverage
6 publishers- Builder
- Builder 6%
- Operator
- Operator 24%
- Investor
- Investor 70%
Claim ledger
Ranked by verification strength, evidence, and original report placement.
- [1]
A family of barn owls nested in a water tower atop a building on West 75th Street close to Central Park West in Manhattan's Upper West Side.
- [2]
Andrew Farnsworth, a migration ecologist at the Cornell Lab of Ornithology, said: "To the best of our knowledge, like the collective birding knowledge, there hasn't been a nest in, you know, in Manhattan, at least in recorded history."
- [3]
Farnsworth said of the barn owls: "It was, like, totally shocking."
- [4]
Upper West Side resident Elisabeth Williams notified a local news outlet on Oct. 6 that she and her husband saw multiple owls at the water tower atop a building on West 75th Street.
- [5]
Williams and her husband heard periodic screeching noises outside going back to early September, and were skeptical when a phone app indicated the noise was from a barn owl.
- [6]
Barn owl sightings in New York City parks are very rare, according to the New York City Department of Parks & Recreation.
- [7]
New York is at the northern fringe of the barn owl's range.
- [8]
The barn owl population has declined "at an alarming rate" over time, according to the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation.
- [9]
Photographers and casual onlookers have gathered on the street on a nightly basis to spot the owls.
- [10]
Barrett said: "Having one barn owl is a rarity, but it's not national news. Having a family, for the first time ever, breeding in Manhattan in recorded history, that's special news."
- [11]
Val Coleman, a retired New York City resident trying to spot the owls, said: "At dusk, we hope they will come out to hunt. We hope they don't eat poisoned rats with rodenticide in 'em."
- [12]
David Barrett, a Manhattan-based birder who runs the Manhattan Bird Alert social media account, said he has observed at least one adult barn owl and five fledglings at the water tower.
- [13]
Barrett has also seen an adult owl carrying rodents back to the water tower.
- [14]
There are believed to be two adult owls, and some photographers have claimed to have seen six fledglings, Barrett added.
Sources
3 independent publishers whose own reporting we read for this story.
- abcnews.comA rare family of barn owls moved into Manhattan. New Yorkers are captivated
1 article · October 15, 2026
- cbsnews.comFamily of barn owls on the Upper West Side captivates New York City birders
1 article · October 12, 2026
- fortune.comWho’s there? A rare family of barn owls takes over a water tower in Manhattan’s Upper West Side
1 article · October 15, 2026
- independent.co.ukExtremely rare barn owl sighting draws crowds to New York's Upper West Side
1 article · October 15, 2026
- phys.orgA rare family of barn owls moved into Manhattan's Upper West Side. New Yorkers are captivated
1 article · October 15, 2026
- A Family of Barn Owls Has Moved Into New York City's Upper West Side, Perhaps the First to Nest in Manhattan in Modern History
smithsonianmag.com
1 article · October 13, 2026
Topics and entities
Topics
Entities
- NYC Bird Alliance
- Manhattan Bird Alert
- Andrew Farnsworth
- Cornell Lab of Ornithology