Skip to content
Today
Sections

Leadership Independently confirmed2 publishers 2 min read Published

Reports of an 8% bank surcharge take about 2% off Lloyds and NatWest

Lloyds and NatWest fell about 2% on Friday after reports that Chancellor John Healey may restore the bank profit surcharge to 8% from 3%. The TUC puts the yield at £2.25bn a year, but the Treasury has not confirmed the option ahead of the October 28 Budget.

The Board Room · Leadership desk

Send a correction

Surcharge yields are a fraction of the buffer lost Annual revenue the TUC puts on two bank surcharge rises, beside the IPPR's estimate of how far the Chancellor's fiscal buffer has fallen since the spring.

Key figures: the TUC says the tax rise on banks' profits would raise £2.25bn a year. The IPPR estimates the Chancellor's fiscal buffer has dropped by up to £15bn since the spring. The TUC's 16% surcharge would raise about £6bn a year.

Surcharge yields are a fraction of the buffer lost
FigureValueNoteClaim
TUC estimate, tax rise on bank profits£2.25bn a year7
Fiscal buffer drop since spring, up to£15bnIPPR estimate14
TUC's 16% ask, about£6bn a year21

What happened

  • The option traces to a Guardian report that the Chancellor is weighing a reversal of the cut made under former Conservative chancellor Jeremy Hunt.
  • Shortly after 8:30am Lloyds was down 1.9% at 103.85p and NatWest down 1.8% at 662.2p, according to Proactiveinvestors NA.
  • The IPPR, a think tank, this week recommended £1bn from a temporary windfall surcharge on banks within a package meant to raise an extra £16bn.
  • UK Finance, the banks' trade body, said a rise in bank taxes at the Budget "would weaken the UK's competitiveness, discourage investment and job creation".

Why it matters

  • Who has to decide decision Finance teams have to choose a planning rate for a charge that is reported but not announced, with the Budget 12 days after the share fall.
  • What it limits constraint At the IPPR's upper estimate of a £15bn loss in the Chancellor's fiscal buffer, £2.25bn recovers 15% of it, so a bank surcharge alone would not rebuild the buffer.
  • What it sets up precedent The TUC's 16% ask works out at £6bn a year, about 2.7 times its figure for 8%. That higher reference point makes a reversion to 8% look moderate.

Next story · Leadership · yesterday

Healey is poised to tax banks harder in the 28 October budget, the Guardian understands

Confirmed3 publishers

A 2% move on a newspaper report [2] says little about the odds that the Chancellor acts. The fall was confined to lenders: Barclays slipped as well [1], while the FTSE 100 was down only 0.1% shortly after 8:30 [4].

Scale is the harder question. Proactiveinvestors NA says a reversal could raise more than £2bn a year [8], and the TUC says £2.25bn [7]. Proactiveinvestors NA also gives a figure it credits to the Guardian: around £200bn of pre-tax profit over five years for HSBC, NatWest, Barclays and Lloyds [23]. That is about £40bn a year [25], and £2.25bn is about 5.6% of it [18]. The comparison is rough, because banks pay the surcharge on qualifying profits on top of corporation tax [5]. The sources do not give the yield by lender, the period behind the TUC's profit figure, or a start date for any change.

TUC general secretary Paul Nowak said: "Britain's big four banks are making a billion pounds a week, while bonuses have hit a post-crash record." [24] The five-year total implies about £770m a week [26].

The sector's defenders make a competitiveness case. Louise Hellem, the CBI's chief economist, said the Budget should avoid further sector-specific taxation, including "on a banking sector already facing a higher tax rate than competing international financial centres" [11]. The Chancellor's case is about revenue. He is looking for ways to raise money and hold the deficit down as government borrowing costs soar [12], and those costs have risen on inflation fears tied to the US war with Iran [15].

The trade-off is revenue against the investment and competitiveness that UK Finance and the CBI say is at stake [10][11]. For a finance team, this quarter's decision is a planning case, and next quarter's consequence is whichever rate the Budget sets. We think a case at 8% is the sensible base, because it is the only rate reported as under consideration [2]. If the Budget adopts a temporary charge of the kind the IPPR proposed [9], an open-ended 8% case would overstate the later years.

What to watch

  • Whether the Chancellor confirms or drops the surcharge option before or in the October 28 Budget statement.
  • Whether the Budget names a rate, a start date and whether the charge is temporary or open-ended.
  • Whether Lloyds and NatWest recover the 2% once the Budget text is out.

Clarity's read

What the record supports and how the coverage leans. The claims behind it follow.

Reality

Evidence45
Adoption
Not scored
Hype gap+25
Incentives70
Confidence58

Perspective Coverage

3 publishers
Builder
Builder 3%
Operator
Operator 35%
Investor
Investor 62%
Why these scores

Claim ledger

Ranked by verification strength, evidence, and original report placement.

  1. [1]

    Lloyds Banking Group and NatWest led falls on the FTSE 100 on Friday, both down 2% in morning trading, with Barclays shares also slipping after reports that John Healey is eyeing a raid on lenders.

    Reported SupportedView cited source
  2. [2]

    One option the Chancellor is considering is reversing former Tory chancellor Jeremy Hunt's reduction in the bank profit surcharge from 8% to 3%, according to a report in the Guardian.

    Reported Supported Source: The Independent, citing a Guardian reportView cited source
  3. [3]

    Shortly after 8:30 on Friday Lloyds fell 1.9% to 103.85p and NatWest dropped 1.8% to 662.2p.

    Reported SupportedView cited source
  4. [4]

    The FTSE 100 was down 0.1% at 10,826.31 shortly after 8:30am.

    Reported SupportedView cited source
  5. [5]

    Banks already pay the surcharge on qualifying profits in addition to corporation tax.

    Reported SupportedView cited source
  6. [6]

    The Proactiveinvestors NA report on the share move is dated 16 October 2026 and refers to Friday trading.

    Reported SupportedView cited source
  7. [7]

    TUC general secretary Paul Nowak backed the move, saying the tax rise on banks' profits would raise £2.25 billion a year.

    Reported Supported Source: TUC, as reported by The IndependentView cited source
  8. [8]

    Reversing the previous cut in the bank surcharge, taking the rate back to 8% from 3%, could raise more than £2 billion a year.

    Reported Supported Source: Proactiveinvestors NA, which says the option is 'understood' to be under considerationView cited source
  9. [9]

    The Institute for Public Policy Research this week recommended generating £1 billion from a temporary surcharge on commercial banks' windfall profits, within a package of measures to raise an extra £16 billion.

    Reported SupportedView cited source
  10. [10]

    A UK Finance spokesperson said an increase in bank taxes at the Budget "would weaken the UK's competitiveness, discourage investment and job creation".

    Reported Supported Source: UK Finance, the banking sector's trade bodyView cited source
  11. [11]

    Louise Hellem, chief economist at the CBI, said the Budget should avoid further sector-specific taxation, including "on a banking sector already facing a higher tax rate than competing international financial centres".

    Reported Supported Source: Louise Hellem, CBIView cited source
  12. [12]

    The Chancellor is seeking ways to raise revenue and keep the UK's budget deficit under control in the face of soaring Government borrowing costs.

    Reported SupportedView cited source
  13. [13]

    The Budget is on October 28, and Mr Healey has warned the public to be prepared for a tough Budget.

    Reported SupportedView cited source
  14. [14]

    The IPPR estimated that the Chancellor's fiscal buffer has dropped by up to £15 billion since the spring.

    Reported Supported Source: Institute for Public Policy ResearchView cited source
  15. [15]

    Government borrowing costs have soared due to fears over inflation driven by the US's war with Iran.

    Reported SupportedView cited source
  16. [16]

    A Treasury spokesperson said decisions on tax are a matter for the Chancellor to set out at fiscal events, rather than routinely commenting on rumour, speculation or proposals.

    Reported Supported Source: Treasury spokespersonView cited source
  17. [17]

    The TUC called for a bigger surcharge increase, to 16%, saying that could raise £24 billion in tax revenues over four years.

    Reported Supported Source: TUCView cited source
  18. [18]

    The TUC's £2.25bn a year is about 5.6% of the four largest lenders' average annual pre-tax profit.

    Derived Supported
  19. [19]

    The Budget falls 12 days after Friday 16 October.

    Derived Supported
  20. [20]

    At the IPPR's upper estimate of a £15bn loss in the fiscal buffer, £2.25bn is 15% of it.

    Derived Supported
  21. [21]

    The TUC's 16% surcharge would raise about £6bn a year.

    Derived Supported
  22. [22]

    The TUC's 16% option at £6bn a year is about 2.7 times its £2.25bn figure for the 8% option.

    Derived Supported
  23. [23]

    Britain's largest lenders, including HSBC, NatWest, Barclays and Lloyds, have generated around £200 billion in pre-tax profits over the past five years as higher interest rates boosted earnings.

    Reported Contested Source: Proactiveinvestors NA, crediting the GuardianView cited source
  24. [24]

    Paul Nowak, TUC general secretary, said: "Britain's big four banks are making a billion pounds a week, while bonuses have hit a post-crash record."

    Reported Contested Source: Paul Nowak, TUCView cited source
  25. [25]

    The four largest lenders' pre-tax profit averaged about £40bn a year over five years.

    Derived Contested
  26. [26]

    A £40bn annual profit implies about £770m a week.

    Derived Contested

Sources

2 independent publishers whose own reporting we read for this story.

  1. independent.co.uk

    1 article · October 16, 2026

    Bank shares drop on reports Chancellor planning Budget tax raid | The Independent

  2. lbc.co.uk

    1 article · October 16, 2026

    Bank shares drop on reports Chancellor planning Budget tax raid
  3. proactiveinvestors.com

    1 article · October 16, 2026

    Lloyds and NatWest lead FTSE 100 fallers as bank tax fears return

Topics and entities

Topics

Entities