Skip to content

Topic

Natural History Collections and Holotype Custody

Where museums and biological collections physically hold type specimens, and how that custody governs access for taxonomic work.

Current stories

scienceOne report1 publisher

Museum search finds an 86.6 mm Tennessee bottlebrush crayfish bigger than Crawzilla

Illinois biologist Caitlin Bloomer's nationwide search found an 86.6 mm Tennessee bottlebrush crayfish, the largest specimen it identified. The measurements hint at a common size ceiling, with muscle or shell limits offered as a possible cause.

Publishers:sciencedaily.com

Reality

Evidence55
Adoption
Not scored
Hype gap+15
Incentives
Not scored
Confidence50
scienceOne report1 publisher

Twenty museum specimens put North America's crayfish size ceiling near 80 mm

Biologists with calipers went through museum drawers to compile some of the first upper size thresholds for the group. None of the environmental variables the team tested predicted which animals got big.

Publishers:phys.org

Reality

Evidence58
Adoption
Not scored
Hype gap+18
Incentives62
Confidence61
scienceOne report1 publisher

Museum DNA puts the moss carder bumblebee's genetic diversity down a quarter in a century

DNA from more than 100 museum specimens gives conservationists a century-long baseline for a declining British pollinator. The yearly rate of loss it measures is far too slow for a decade of field monitoring to have caught.

Publishers:phys.org

Reality

Evidence58
Adoption20
Hype gap+18
Incentives62
Confidence55
scienceOne report1 publisher

A Costa Rica expedition's 371 sea snakes carried crabs, shrimp and a clingfish

Joseph Pfaller noticed a crab drop off almost the first yellow-bellied sea snake he handled in 2012, and the larvae he collected then waited about a decade in a Florida museum for a crab specialist to ask what they were.

Publishers:phys.org

Reality

Evidence58
Adoption
Not scored
Hype gap+10
Incentives35
Confidence60
scienceOne report1 publisher

CT scan finds ordinary vertebrae inside the spider-tailed viper's fake spider

The Field Museum holotype was mistaken for a tumour when it arrived in 1968. Sent through an X-ray CT scanner rather than cut open, the bones at the tail tip turned out to be about as normal as any viper's.

Publishers:phys.org

Reality

Evidence62
Adoption18
Hype gap+8
Incentives52
Confidence62
scienceOne report1 publisher

London type specimens pull a widespread Choco frog out of another species' name

A trip to the Natural History Museum's 19th-century Ecuadorian frogs showed the original specimens had been filed against the wrong animal, leaving a loud, common Choco frog with no name of its own until now.

Publishers:sciencedaily.com

Reality

Evidence58
Adoption
Not scored
Hype gap+18
Incentives62
Confidence64
scienceOne report1 publisher

The holotype ledger: 95% of new mammals come from the South, 60% of the specimens do not stay

A Brazilian-led study in npj Biodiversity counts 1,116 mammal species described since 1990 and where their reference specimens ended up. The answer is now a number institutions can be asked about.

Publishers:phys.org

Reality

Evidence71
Adoption21
Hype gap+9
Incentives62
Confidence56