Skip to content

Institute for Justice

Libertarian public interest law firm that litigates civil liberties and property-rights cases, including challenges to warrantless surveillance.

Known aliases

  • IJ

Current stories

productConfirmed4 publishers

Flock has fired no police customer over license-plate abuse, its CEO says

Flock CEO Garrett Langley said the company has ended no contract over abuse, though dozens of officers were arrested, fired or told to resign. He named knowing lawbreaking as the trigger, so a buyer has to write its own rule for smaller cases.

Perspective Coverage

5 publishers
Builder
Builder 17%
Operator
Operator 64%
Investor
Investor 19%

Reality

Evidence50
Adoption
Not scored
Hype gap+30
Incentives70
Confidence68
productConfirmed5 publishers

Judge Sara Hill rules a deputy's warrantless search of Flock's cross-state network unconstitutional

Federal judge Sara E. Hill ruled Oct. 1 that a Tulsa County deputy's warrantless search of Flock's cross-state camera network was unconstitutional. The search she faulted was a plate lookup run without probable cause, the query a plate-reader network is built around, so agencies now have to decide how they control it.

Perspective Coverage

9 publishers
Builder
Builder 15%
Operator
Operator 60%
Investor
Investor 25%

Reality

Evidence78
Adoption65
Hype gap+20
Incentives55
Confidence72
productConfirmed7 publishers

Flock cuts plate-read retention to seven days, and admits defaults beat policy

The licence plate reader company is making most of its new safeguards mandatory on 1 January, after its chief executive conceded that optional abuse controls sat unused at two-thirds of agencies.

Perspective Coverage

7 publishers
Builder
Builder 32%
Operator
Operator 47%
Investor
Investor 21%

Reality

Evidence70
Adoption35
Hype gap+35
Incentives70
Confidence65
productOne report1 publisher

Flock answered Senate scrutiny of plate readers with a dropdown menu and a case number field

Republicans and Democrats on the Senate crime subcommittee both objected that plate reader vendors leave abuse detection to the police departments buying the cameras, and the four invited chief executives did not appear.

Publishers:nextgov.com

Reality

Evidence52
Adoption61
Hype gap+28
Incentives74
Confidence56
productOne report1 publisher

Flock's letter to the Senate puts the search audit on the agencies that buy its cameras

Flock's chief executive sent a Senate subcommittee a letter instead of testifying. It says customer agencies own and control the search records and set retention, and that Flock does very little oversight of how clients search its network.

Publishers:mashable.com

Reality

Evidence58
Adoption60
Hype gap+8
Incentives72
Confidence55
leadershipOne report1 publisher

Flock's 120,000 cameras turn ALPR procurement into a council-floor fight

More than 100 jurisdictions have cancelled Flock contracts and Texas has blocked state purchases, yet opposition to plate readers in one's own community still polls at 46%, and some councils simply switch vendors.

Publishers:theguardian.com

Reality

Evidence54
Adoption71
Hype gap+21
Incentives63
Confidence57
productOne report1 publisher

Both parties now campaign against the plate cameras already running in 6,000 communities

Flock says its license plate readers operate in 6,000 communities in every state but Alaska, and candidates in both parties are now pledging bans, funding pauses and warrant rules, which turns a signed municipal contract into an election-year liability.

Publishers:fastcompany.com

Reality

Evidence58
Adoption70
Hype gap+20
Incentives82
Confidence48
securityOne report1 publisher

A cop, a hot list, and a query log: where ALPR actually fails

Body camera footage of a Florida officer who stalked a woman he met on a TV set shows no perimeter was breached. An authorized user made authorized-looking queries, and nothing stopped him.

Publishers:404media.co

Reality

Evidence74
Adoption68
Hype gap−18
Incentives66
Confidence70
buildOne report1 publisher

Flock cut retention to seven days and published the number that made 30 indefensible

Over 90% of partial-plate searches happen within a week, by Flock's own telemetry. That makes the old 30-day default a capacity finding first and a privacy finding second.

Publishers:dev.to

Reality

Evidence42
Adoption58
Hype gap+12
Incentives74
Confidence40